Will Turner Really Tell NBA To Wait?

Stop me if you’ve heard this one. Johnny All-Star drops hints during the season that he’s thinking seriously about returning to State U for another year only to seize the first available opportunity to jump to the professional ranks.

It happens all the time at almost every school. Jim Jackson, Chris Gamble, Mike Conley Jr. and Beanie Wells are just a handful of the Ohio State examples of former players who decided million-dollar pro contracts trumped another season of college life.

As with every rule, however, there are exceptions. Mike Doss, A.J. Hawk and James Laurinaitis are OSU football players who decided to forgo NFL riches in lieu of one more year of college ball. When it comes to basketball Buckeyes, though, the ones who chose staying over leaving are few and far between.

Evan Turner may be different. When the junior star indicated Feb. 26 that he was open to returning to Ohio State for his senior season, I got the impression that it wasn’t merely a throwaway line for the media as the Buckeyes tried to focus on a third Big Ten championship in five seasons.

It seemed Turner was genuinely interested in returning to OSU next season.

Turner seems to walk to a little different drumbeat than most of college basketball’s elite players. While there is little doubt he dreams of being an NBA star one day, he has no illusions about his current game and how much he will have to elevate his performance when he enters the league.

There is also something a little more cerebral about Turner than your garden variety college athlete. Not only is he a student of his game, he is a perfectionist. Many players will claim they have a similar goal but spend very little time trying to achieve that perfection. Not Turner. He appears to realize he remains a work in progress. To that end, he is constantly tweaking his game and therefore is able to consistently show improvement – not only from year to year but often within the course of a single season.

A prime example is Turner’s freshman season with the Buckeyes. He averaged 8.5 points and 4.4 rebounds while starting 30 of 37 games – pretty good stats for any first-year player. But while many freshmen hit the proverbial wall late in the season, Turner peaked down the stretch, and scored a combined 37 points against Mississippi and Massachusetts as Ohio State won the NIT championship.

Despite that performance, Turner worked hard during the offseason to improve his rebounding and that helped result in a sophomore season that included game averages of 17.3 points, 7.1 rebounds and 4.0 assists while starting all 33 games for the Buckeyes.

In the middle of that season, OSU head coach Thad Matta became dissatisfied with the play of his point guards and asked Turner if would be willing to man the position. You don’t have to be John Wooden to know the difference between being a wing player and a point guard, not to mention the discipline it takes to be the on-the-floor quarterback of a basketball team.

You also don’t need to be the Wizard of Westwood to realize how much practice time Turner has invested to reach his comfort level as the Buckeyes’ point guard. During this past offseason, he worked on his ball-handling skills, something he has been doing since he was growing up in the Chicago suburbs. He also spent time – a lot of it – on perfecting his jump shot because he realized few opposing teams have defensive answers for a 6-7 point guard who can consistently make pull-up jumpers.

The result? Turner has improved on last year’s numbers that nearly won him Big Ten Player of the Year honors. With one game remaining in the regular season, he was averaging 19.7 points, 9.3 rebounds and 5.9 assists per game. He had also raised his shooting percentage from 50.3 percent last season to 54.3 this year, and cut his assists-to-turnovers ratio by more than 20 percent.

Best of all, Turner gets it. As Matta put it recently, his star player is not playing with one foot out the door, understanding that while the NBA will make him a rich young man, the mere realization of a lifelong dream doesn’t translate into instant success.

“I don’t want to go to the league and sit on the bench,” Turner told reporters Feb. 26. “I want to go to the league and play right away and be an impact player. I want to make sure I’m fully ready. I don’t want to go into a situation where I’m not ready and not be the best I can right away.”

At the risk of overstating the obvious, it would mean a lot to Ohio State basketball should Turner truly return next season. In fact, it could be the kind of thing that finally elevates Matta’s program to elite national status.

Turner’s return for 2010-11 would likely entice David Lighty and William Buford to stay another season as well (if either player is truly thinking about leaving), and with all five starters back the Buckeyes would be overwhelming preseason favorites to win another Big Ten championship. Add to that another sterling recruiting class signed by Matta, and the conference title would be only the beginning.

Success breeds success, and that kind of team would not only put more fannies in the seats at Value City Arena, it would also help Matta continue to restock his roster with the best high school talent the nation has to offer. Additionally, another league championship and possible Final Four run couldn’t help but pump a few extra bucks into the Ohio State athletic department bank account, another facet of success that cannot be discounted.

Turner is no dummy. If he thinks he can make it in the NBA next year, he’s gone. After all, why does one attend college in the first place? Isn’t it simply a means to increase your future earning power? How many business school students would choose to finish their degree work if a Fortune 500 company came calling with a multimillion-dollar contract following their junior years? Not many.

Still, there is always something to be said for college life. For professional athletes, the money is going to be there. But for all those zeroes on that contract, your senior year on campus is something you can never get back.

Turner is one of those increasingly-rare players who seems to understand that. Like Doss, Hawk and Laurinaitis before him, he seems to embrace college life and it would appear to embrace him back. Turner is one of the most popular figures on the Ohio State campus – and that’s saying something at a traditional football school – and he has forged relationships and friendships he admittedly enjoys.

Of course, it’s his decision whether or not to return for one more season as a Buckeye and millions of dollars would turn the head of any young man. Turner is not just any young man, however, and that’s why the answer may be different this time.


Today is a big day for birthdays in the Buckeye Nation with former basketball coach Gary Williams and former football players Lenny Willis, Doug Plank and Robert Smith celebrating.

Gary B. Williams was born March 4, 1945, in Collinswood, N.J., and was a starting point guard at Maryland in the mid-1960s. He began his coaching career at Woodrow Wilson High School in Camden, N.J., and won a state championship there. Williams joined the college ranks in 1972 as an assistant at Lafayette where he was also the school’s head soccer coach. Williams spent two seasons at Lafayette and two more at Boston College before landing his first head coaching job in 1978 at American University. He went on to head the programs at Boston College and Ohio State before returning to Maryland. Williams, who won the 2002 NCAA championship with the Terrapins, was 59-41 in three seasons with the Buckeyes from 1987-89, and his 1988 team was NIT runner-up.

Douglas Walter Plank was born March 4, 1953, in Greensburg, Pa., and was a three-year letterman defensive back for the Buckeyes from 1972-74. He was a 12th-round draft choice by Chicago in the 1975 NFL draft, and wound up becoming the first rookie to lead the Bears in tackles. Plank wound up playing eight seasons with the Bears and he became such a favorite of Chicago defensive coordinator Buddy Ryan that Ryan named his famed “46 defense” after Plank’s jersey number. After his playing days were over, Plank went into coaching – first in the Arena Football League and later in the NFL. This past season, he served as assistant defensive backfield coach for the New York Jets.

Leonard Leroy Willis was born March 4, 1953, in Washington, D.C., and was a three-sport star in high school before becoming an All-American at JUCO. Willis transferred to Ohio State in 1974 and became a football and track star for the Buckeyes. He led the Big Ten in kickoff returns in ’74 and ’75, and established a school record that still stands when he returned two kickoffs for touchdowns against Oregon State in 1974. Willis was Minnesota’s fourth-round selection in the 1976 NFL draft, and he played four seasons as a kick returner for the Vikings, Saints and Bills. He later played several seasons in the old USFL before beginning a coaching career in 1985 on Earle Bruce’s staff at Ohio State. Since 2002, Willis has been director of facilities at the University of Illinois.

Robert Scott Smith was born March 4, 1972, in Euclid, Ohio, and came to Ohio State after an All-America prep career at his hometown high school. Smith broke Archie Griffin’s freshman rushing record with 1,126 yards in 1990 but then sat out the 1991 season in a dispute over academics with then offensive coordinator Elliot Uzelac. Smith returned in 1992 and led the Buckeyes in rushing with 819 yards before making himself eligible for the NFL draft. The Minnesota Vikings selected him with the 21st pick of the first round, and Smith finished his eight-year career as the team’s all-time leading rusher. He also earned two Pro Bowl selections. Smith is currently a college football analyst for ESPN.

Also celebrating birthdays this 4th day of March: Texas Gov. Rick Perry is 60; Philadelphia Phillies third base coach Sam Perlozzo is 59; pro golfer Peter Jacobsen is 56; actress Catherine O’Hara is 56; actress Patricia Heaton (Debra Barone in “Everybody Loves Raymond”) is 52; actor Mykelti Williamson (Pvt. Benjamin Buford “Bubba” Blue in “Forrest Gump”) is 50; former lightweight boxing champion Ray Mancini is 49; former NBA all-star guard and current Sacramento, Calif., mayor Kevin Johnson is 44; gay rights activist Chaz (born Chastity) Bono is 41; and Cincinnati Bengals safety Chinedum Ndukwe is 25.


** Ohio State isn’t the only school to monkey with the early part of its 2010 football schedule. Utah has moved its opener against Pittsburgh to Sept. 2, most likely the second game of a primetime doubleheader that begins with the Buckeyes hosting Marshall. Meanwhile, Toledo will host Arizona the following evening for a Friday night affair televised by ESPN, and the season-opening weekend culminates Labor Day night when Boise State and Virginia Tech square off in primetime at FedEx Field in Landover, Md.

** Here is some trivia for you: Name the first football coach ever to win 100 or more games both at the collegiate and professional levels. The answer comes later.

** Ohio State vs. defending national champion Alabama in next year’s BCS National Championship Game? That’s how ESPN.com writer Mark Schlabach envisions the end of the 2010 college football season. He ranks the Crimson Tide and the Buckeyes atop his preseason top 25 with Boise State, Oregon and Virginia Tech rounding out the top five. Schlabach also has three other Big Ten schools in his rankings – Wisconsin at No. 9, Iowa at No. 12 and Penn State at No. 22.

** If you like the blue turf at Boise State, you’re really going to love this. Division I-AA Eastern Washington has announced plans to install a red playing surface at its Woodward Field facility in Cheney, Wash. How long before Nike suggests installation of a yellow field at Oregon’s Autzen Stadium?

** The trivia answer is Don Coryell, who went 104-19-2 from in 12 seasons at San Diego State from 1961-72 and then posted a 111-83-1 mark in the NFL as head coach of the St. Louis Cardinals (1973-77) and San Diego Chargers (1978-86). If you guessed former Ohio State All-American end Sid Gillman, you were close. The innovative Gillman posted a 122-99-7 record in the pro ranks with the Chargers, Rams and Oilers, and was 81-19-2 in 10 college seasons at Miami (Ohio) and Cincinnati. Interestingly, Coryell has always maintained that he was heavily influenced by Gillman and routinely took his entire San Diego State team to Chargers workouts to observe how Gillman ran his practice sessions.

Ranking OSU’s Best Tailbacks Redux

In the nearly 14 months since I listed my top 10 Ohio State tailbacks of all-time, I have received a steady stream of e-mails critical of the list. Most of what I have heard has to do with the omission of Chris “Beanie” Wells although most of my electronic pen pals don’t seem to realize I formulated my list before the 2008 season – which would be Wells’ final one as a Buckeye.

It seems like as good a time as any to go back and take a second look at my list with the first question being: Does Wells belong on it?

Of course he does. Wells finished his career with the fourth highest rushing total in Ohio State history. But I have to be honest. I can’t remember a player in recent history whose career in which I have been more disappointed.

You may think it sound ridiculous to criticize Wells, especially when you look at the raw numbers. Only Archie Griffin, Eddie George and Tim Spencer ever rushed for more yards in scarlet and gray. Wells put together back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons, only the sixth OSU running back ever to accomplish that feat. His 222-yard effort at Michigan in 2007 is the most yards ever gained by an Ohio State runner in the long history of that series.

And still there is this nagging feeling in my mind that there could have been even more. In my mind, Wells could have gone down in history as one of the all-time greatest running backs in college football. He had the talent, the size, the speed. Somewhere along the line, it just didn’t happen.

First of all, there were the nagging injuries. Even so, you are never going to hear me say Wells was soft. Sometimes, injuries cling to a player like white on a baseball. Wells was one of those players. In only three seasons with the Buckeyes, he had hand, leg and wrist problems not to mention the toe injury he suffered in last season’s opener that cost him three games and parts of two others. Wells played with most of those injuries when lesser players would have not.

Still, the 6-1, 237-pounder was sort of a walking contradiction. He had some of the longest touchdown runs in recent memory, yet seemed strangely unable to pick up needed yardage on third-and-short. He had some three inches and nearly 40 pounds on teammate Maurice Wells, yet it was the latter that was often called upon in obvious passing situations because he provided the better pass protection.

Maybe Beanie is another one of the cautionary tales of recruiting. He was ranked second nationally by Scout.com in 2006 (behind only current USC quarterback Mitch Mustain) but ahead of such players as quarterback Matthew Stafford of Georgia, receiver Percy Harvin of Florida and quarterback Tim Tebow of Florida.

There is no doubt Wells had an excellent career at Ohio State. I guess maybe I was just expecting a little more.

With that, I have taken another look at my all-time top 10 Ohio State running backs and jumbled the list somewhat. See how it stacks up to yours.

1. Eddie George (1992-95) – I moved Eddie to the top of the list because he was a workhorse and always answered the bell. I wrote this the last time and it bears repeating: Watching George break through the line was like watching Secretariat break from the gate. The fact that he went on to such a productive NFL career was no surprise. His senior season in 1995, when he rushed for 1,927 yards and won the Heisman, is the gold standard for all Buckeyes who follow. Perhaps the most astounding thing about that season – every opposing defensive coordinator knew George was coming and was powerless to stop him. He averaged 5.9 yards per carry and 25.2 carries per game.

2. Archie Griffin (1972-75) – How do you measure heart? Archie was never going to be the biggest or the fastest running back on the roster, but you knew when you gave him the football that he was going to figure out a way to pick up the yards he needed. He maximized his talents through hard work and determination, and it didn’t hurt that he played behind a massive offensive line and one of the best blocking fullbacks (Pete Johnson) in college football history. Griffin’s career mark of 5,589 rushing yards still stands nearly 35 years after he played his last game at OSU – and no one has come within 1,800 yards of that record. Oh, yeah. He’s still the only guy ever with two Heismans.

3. Keith Byars (1982-85) – Byars was the top guy on last year’s list, but I took a second look and decided that he didn’t quite measure up to George or Griffin. IMHO, the senior season lost because of a foot injury costs him in the all-time rankings. Still, his 1984 season should never be diminished. He rushed for 1,764 yards and scored 22 touchdowns on 336 carries, a single-season workload that has never been equaled. Byars was also a dangerous weapon in the passing game, and he went on to catch 610 passes during a 14-year NFL career.

4. Howard “Hopalong” Cassady (1952-55) – Cassady has become a larger-than-life figure over the past 50 years, but many of today’s fans don’t know that he was a little guy by today’s standards. The freckle-faced, redheaded kid from Columbus Central High School was only 5-10 and about 170 pounds, but he could fly. He scored three touchdowns in his first college game and went on to become one of the greats in college football history. In 1955, he won one of the most lopsided Heisman votes in history, polling 2,219 points, nearly three times the total of the second-place finisher. Cassady was also the consummate teammate, leading Woody Hayes to say, “Hop is the most inspirational player I have ever seen.” Good enough for me.

5. Vic Janowicz (1949-51) – On sheer athletic ability alone, Janowicz had few equals. He could run, throw and kick a football with the best of them and had enough talent to become one of the few players to enjoy professional careers in both the NFL and Major League Baseball. The coaching change from Wes Fesler to Hayes in 1951 – and the philosophy change that went with it – robbed Janowicz of possibly becoming the first two-time Heisman winner. But those who remember his 1950 season remember a blur who ran past opponents and scored touchdowns in bunches. Oldtimers still talk in hushed tones about his performance in an 81-23 win over Iowa – he scored three touchdowns – two rushing and a 61-yard punt return – threw for four scores, recovered two fumbles on defense and kicked 10 extra points. Not a bad day’s work.

6. Tim Spencer (1979-82) – Spencer would likely have been higher on this list had he not served as a fullback for his first two seasons. And he was an excellent fullback, too, blocking for Calvin Murray and also carrying the ball with authority (back when OSU allowed the fullback to carry in tandem with the tailback.) Once Spence got the tailback spot to himself, though, he blossomed with a combination of speed and upper-body strength that blew through would-be tacklers. He totaled 1,217 yards in his first year as a starter and then upped that total to 1,538 in his senior year of 1982. That figure is still the fifth-best single-season total in school history.

7. Antonio Pittman (2004-06) – Largely the forgotten man in an offense that featured Troy Smith and Ted Ginn Jr., Pittman’s workmanlike approach to the tailback position allowed the Buckeyes to become a more multifaceted offense in 2005 and ’06. He was remarkably consistent during his two seasons as the starter – 1,331 yards as a sophomore and 1,233 as a junior – and turned himself into a pretty good receiver as well. Pittman would likely be higher on this list had he returned in 2007 for his senior season.

8. Chris “Beanie” Wells (2006-08) – And Wells would likely be higher, too, had he returned in 2009 for his senior season. Unfortunately, we never got to see him play an entire season injury-free. What we did get to see, however, was a guy who finished among the top five in nearly every career rushing category on the Ohio State record books.

9. Chic Harley (1916-17, 1919) – Simply put, Harley was the catalyst for what eventually became Ohio State football as we know it today. I could list his statistics, some of which would pale in comparison to the numbers average players put up these days. Rather, I’ll list just a handful for Harley’s accomplishments – Ohio State’s first three-time All-American, the first man ever to lead the Buckeyes to a victory over Michigan, the first to lead them to an undefeated season and the first to lead the Scarlet and Gray to a conference championship.

10. Robert Smith (1990, 1992) – Smith is another guy whose star would have burned much brighter if not for missed opportunities. He was an extremely gifted running back whose seemingly effortless strides allowed him to set the OSU freshman record in 1990 with 1,126 yards. Unfortunately, his college career got off-track for a variety of reasons – some of Smith’s own creation – and he never fully realized his great potential. Nevertheless, the all-too-brief flashes he showed in scarlet and gray make him deserving to be in my top 10.

One final note: There are those who are going to make the argument that players such as Cassady, Janowicz and Harley have no place on a list like this because of the advances football has made since they played the game. That is utter nonsense. Star power is star power, and those guys had it. Anyone who thinks they aren’t among the top 10 running backs in Ohio State football history simply doesn’t know much about Ohio State football history.

If you would like to take a look at my top 10 players at other positions, here are the links:

OSU’s Top 10 Quarterbacks

OSU’s Top 10 Fullbacks

OSU’s Top 10 Wide Receivers

OSU’s Top 10 Tight Ends

OSU’s Top 10 Offensive Guards

OSU’s Top 10 Offensive Tackles


Among those celebrating birthdays this 6th day of August: Seventies TV actor Peter Bonerz (wisecracking dentist Dr. Jerry Robinson on “The Bob Newhart Show”) is 71; professional poker player Lyle Berman is 68; former MLB pitcher Andy Messersmith is 64; former MLB slugger Bob Horner is 52; former NBA star Dale Ellis is 49; actress Michelle Yeoh (Yu Shu-lien in “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon”) is 47; Basketball Hall of Fame center David Robinson is 44; ESPN Radio personality Mike Greenberg is 42; film director M. Night Shyamalan is 39; ex-Spice Girl Geri Halliwell is 37; HBO boxing analyst Max Kellerman is 36; Eighties TV actress Soleil Moon Frye (“Punky Brewster”) is 33; and Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue cover girl Marisa Miller is 31.


** You are no doubt aware that former Ohio State running back Maurice Clarett has withdrawn his petition for early release from prison so that he could resurrect his NFL career. Clarett sent a letter Monday to the Ohio Parole Board explaining his decision, and while letters of those nature are not made public, speculation is that prosecutors in the case opposed the move, there was no chance Clarett was going to receive clemency at this time. The ex-Buckeye began in September 2006 serving a 7½-year sentence for a holdup outside a Columbus bar and a separate highway chase that ended with police finding loaded guns in his SUV. As part of a sentence agreement, he must serve at least 3½ years, which would keep him incarcerated until at least March 2010. “I’m a man and I struggle,” Clarett wrote Monday on his blog. “I’m not speaking of anything specific. I’m just talking in general. Depression comes and depression goes. … I personally believe that I’ve been aiming too low. A body and mind full of endless possibilities that I cannot and will not waste it back here.”

** The Big Ten has only two teams in the Sporting News’ preseason top 25 but five more in SN’s rankings of 26-50. Ohio State is the top conference team in the rankings, coming in at No. 9, while Penn State sits at No. 12. Then it’s a long way down to Iowa at No. 26 and Michigan State at No. 31. The head-scratcher is Michigan at No. 38 (because I don’t think the Wolverines will have a winning record in 2009). Wisconsin is at No. 47 and Minnesota is No. 50.

** When contacted about his team’s ranking, Minnesota defensive lineman Garrett Brown was more than a little miffed. “Everyone knows the Gophers should be ranked in the top 25,” he said. “Don’t make the Gophers angry. You all know the gopher as a happy, smiling little critter. But wait until that critter turns on his critics. He won’t be so happy then.” Sorry, Garrett, but I don’t think your team is going to finish above .500.

** College football kicks off its 2009 season later this month, and that means college basketball is also just around the corner. ESPN analyst Dick Vitale has released his preseason top 40 with Kansas leading the parade. Three Big Ten schools – Michigan State, Purdue and Illinois – are in the top 10 and Ohio State makes an appearance at No. 24. Vitale writes, “If B.J. Mullens had returned, the Buckeyes would have probably been in the top 15. They do have Evan Turner, though, who is one of the best players in the Big Ten.”

** ESPN analyst Andy Katz has also released his preseason top 25 and Katz thinks a little more of the Buckeyes than Vitale, ranking them at No. 16.

** As a Cincinnati Bengals fan, it is with a great deal of trepidation that I await the Aug. 12 premiere of HBO’s “Hard Knocks: Training Camp with the Cincinnati Bengals.” I figure the series will be somewhere between a Jerry Springer episode and those other insipid reality shows that currently litter the airwaves. Let the train wreck begin.